The Martini Shot
4 out of 5
reviewers agree.
I’m the fifth guy.
We came
we saw
we roasted.
The Martini Shot

Editorial Standards

How scores, independence, conflicts, corrections, and the general business of having opinions are handled.

The short version

The Martini Shot publishes independent film criticism. Reviews represent the critic’s judgment after watching the work. Scores are not negotiated with studios, distributors, publicists, advertisers, streaming services, or anyone else who might prefer a different number.

Reviews and scores

Reviews use a five-star scale. The written review controls; the number is a shorthand, not a substitute for reading. For internal data portability, ratings may also be stored as a normalized 0–100 value, but the public score remains the five-star rating shown with the review.

Advertising and commercial relationships

Advertising, sponsorship, affiliate arrangements, screening access, or other commercial relationships do not give a third party approval over editorial coverage, language, conclusions, or scores. Paid placements are labeled as advertising or sponsorship and kept visually distinct from reviews.

Screeners and access

Receiving advance access, a press screening invitation, a screener, travel access, or other ordinary press accommodation does not guarantee coverage or affect a review. Any unusual material relationship that could reasonably bear on a review should be disclosed.

Authorship

Reviews are published under the byline Seamus Maguire. The byline is a pen name used consistently across the publication. Reviews are human-authored film criticism; editing and production tools may assist with ordinary publishing mechanics, but they do not replace the critic’s viewing, judgment, or authorship.

Corrections

Factual errors should be corrected promptly and transparently when material. See the Corrections Policy.